How to Choose the Perfect Stand Up Paddleboard

Posted on by

How to Choose the Perfect Stand Up Paddleboard (SUP): A No-BS Guide from Someone Who’s Been There

Okay, let me just get this out of the way…

I was not always a paddleboarding pro. In fact, the first time I ever tried to stand up on a board, I face-planted into the water so hard I think the fish held an intervention.

But that’s exactly why I’m writing this. Because choosing the right stand up paddleboard (SUP) can be the difference between gliding like a sea god across the water… or becoming a very soggy cautionary tale like yours truly once was.

So let’s break it down—no jargon, no gatekeeping, just the real stuff you need to know when choosing your perfect paddleboard.

First Things First: Know Thyself (and Where You’ll Paddle)

Before you even glance at a paddleboard, ask yourself three questions:

  1. Where are you paddling? (Lake? Ocean? River?)

  2. What’s your skill level? (Be honest. “Watched a YouTube video once” doesn’t count.)

  3. What do you want to do on the board? (Yoga? Racing? Floating around like a chill cucumber?)

For example, I live near a mellow bay, so I wanted something stable enough to chill on but nimble enough to get me moving when I needed it. If you’re paddling open ocean swells and you intend to paddleboard surf then you’re in a whole different ballgame—think more rocker, less chill.

SUP Size Matters (But It’s Not What You Think)

So here’s the thing about size…

Bigger doesn’t always mean better. But sometimes, it does.

Let me explain.

  • Length: Longer boards = faster glide. Great for touring or racing. But harder to maneuver. I once borrowed a 12’6″ board to paddle a narrow canal and ended up spinning in circles like a confused duck.

  • Width: Wider boards = more stability. If you’re just starting, aim for 30” or wider. Don’t worry—nobody’s judging your balance.

  • Thickness: Most boards hover around 5–6 inches. Thicker boards float better (especially for heavier paddlers or if you’re bringing a cooler, dog, or toddler), but may sit higher in the water and catch wind.

My first paddleboard was 10’6” x 32” x 6”. That thing was a floating sofa—super forgiving, super slow. Perfect training wheels for a wobbly newbie.

Hardboard or Inflatable? The Showdown

Ah, the age-old question: rigid or inflatable?

Here’s the quick and dirty:

Inflatable SUPs (iSUPs)

  • Portable AF—fits in your trunk or closet

  • Cushy on your feet and knees

  • Takes 5–10 minutes to inflate (unless you enjoy a workout before your workout)

  • Great for beginners, travelers, and casual paddlers

I’m a big fan. I can chuck mine in the backseat and be at the lake by lunch. Just remember: cheap inflatables are like inflatable mattresses—they look fun until you’re sinking.

Hardboards (Epoxy/Fiberglass)

  • Better performance, speed, and tracking

  • Feels more “connected” to the water

  • Requires roof racks or a truck to haul

  • Dings like your grandma’s china

If you’re into racing, surfing, or just being a speed demon—this is your jam. But for the average weekend paddler? Inflatable usually wins for convenience.

Shape Up: The Hull Truth

Okay, listen up. The shape of the bottom of the board—called the hull—actually changes everything.

  • Planing Hull: Wide and flat. Great for stability and fun in flat water or small surf. Basically the SUV of paddleboards.

  • Displacement Hull: Pointy and narrow. Cuts through water like a kayak. Better for distance and speed.

If you’re just messing around on lakes or bays, planing is probably your speed. If you’ve got the need for speed, or want to paddle miles along a coastline, go displacement.

Don’t Sleep on the Fins (They Actually Matter)

One of my biggest early mistakes? Ignoring fins.

Thought they were just decoration. Spoiler alert: they’re not.

  • Single Fin: Tracks well, but turns slow. Good for calm water.

  • 2+1 Setup: One big center fin, two smaller side fins. Offers a mix of control and tracking. Common in all-around boards.

  • Tri-Fin (Thruster): Three equal fins. Great for surf-style paddling. Makes turning a breeze.

My advice? Unless you’re surfing or racing, go with a standard 2+1. Keeps things simple.

Weight Limit ≠ Suggestion

Here’s the brutal truth: if you overload your board, you’re going swimming.

Check the board’s weight capacity before buying. That includes you plus any gear, dogs, small humans, etc.

I’m around 195 lbs, and once I tried a board rated for 200. Let’s just say… my feet were never dry. Now I go for boards with 250+ lbs capacity. Float like a butterfly, don’t sink like a brick

Accessories You’ll Be Glad You Got

Let’s talk extras. Some are must-haves. Others… not so much.

Must-Haves:

  • Leash: Keeps the board attached to your ankle when you fall (which you will).

  • PFD: Yeah, it’s the law in many places. Get a comfy one.

  • Pump (if inflatable): Electric if you hate sweating. Manual if you’re cheap and stubborn like I was.

Nice-to-Haves:

  • Dry Bag: For your phone, keys, snacks (yes, snacks are essential).

  • Deck Bungees: Straps on the front of the board to stash gear.

  • Carry Strap: Because lugging a board on your hip feels like CrossFit meets comedy.

Try Before You Buy (If You Can)

I know it’s tempting to click Buy Now on that shiny Amazon deal. But if you can try a few boards first—at a rental shop, demo day, or from a friend—it’s a game changer.

I test-rode three boards before I found the one that felt just right. Like Goldilocks, but with more sunscreen and less porridge.

Final Thoughts: Go With What Makes You Want to Paddle More

At the end of the day, the “perfect” paddleboard is the one that makes you excited to get on the water.

Not the one that’s most expensive.
Not the one your buddy swears by.
Not even the one some dude on YouTube called “the best of 2025.”

If it feels stable, fits your needs, and gets you out there with a smile—that’s your board.

The water’s waiting. Get out there and float like you own the lake ‍♂️

Key Takeaways

  • Match your board to your location and goals—don’t just buy what’s trendy.

  • Size matters (especially width and weight capacity for beginners).

  • Inflatable vs. hardboard: Choose based on convenience vs. performance.

  • Hull shape and fin setup affect stability, tracking, and speed.

  • Try before you buy if possible—it’ll save you time and money.

If I can go from flailing newbie to borderline paddleboard snob, trust me—you’re more than ready.

Just don’t forget the sunscreen. And maybe a snack. Always bring snacks.

See ya out there.